| All-Pro team voting | |
| Offense | |
| Position | Player(s) |
| Quarterback | Peyton Manning, Indianapolis, 36 |
| Running backs | Chris Johnson, Tennessee, 50 |
| Adrian Peterson, Minnesota, 17 | |
| Fullback | Leonard Weaver, Philadelphia, 24 |
| Wide receivers | Andre Johnson, Houston, 44 |
| Wes Welker, New England, 20 | |
| Tight end | Dallas Clark, Indianapolis, 25 |
| Offensive tackles | Ryan Clady, Denver, 30 |
| Joe Thomas, Cleveland, 18 | |
| Guards | Steve Hutchinson, Minnesota, 31 |
| Jahri Evans, New Orleans, 28 | |
| Center | Nick Mangold, N.Y. Jets, 31 |
| Defense | |
| Position | Player(s) |
| Defensive ends | Jared Allen, Minnesota, 45 |
| Dwight Freeney, Indianapolis, 36 | |
| Tackles | Jay Ratliff, Dallas, 29 |
| Kevin Williams, Minnesota, 24 | |
| Outside linebackers | Elvis Dumervil, Denver, 46 |
| DaMarcus Ware, Dallas, 37 | |
| Inside linebacker | Patrick Willis, San Francisco, 49 |
| Cornerbacks | Charles Woodson, Green Bay, 48 |
| Darrelle Revis, N.Y. Jets, 48 | |
| Safeties | Darren Sharper, New Orleans, 46 |
| Adrian Wilson, Arizona, 29 | |
| Special teams | |
| Position | Player(s) |
| Punter | Shane Lechler, Oakland, 48 |
| Placekicker | Nate Kaeding, San Diego, 27 |
| Kick returner | Joshua Cribbs, Cleveland, 45 |
