Sonny Gray won 18 games for the Red Sox, finished fifth in the American League Cy Young voting, and is now a Minnesota Twin. He went 18-5 with a 2.72 ERA in Boston, and the Twins announced on Wednesday that they had agreed to a two-year contract with him.
Gray’s money is reportedly $55 million with an opt-out. Fox Sports is the source for that figure, and the breakdown depends on who you read. AP reported a $20 million salary next season and a $30 million player option for 2028, plus a $27.5 million mutual option for 2029 that only applies if he keeps the 2028 money. The sources do not reconcile on how the deal is built, so treat the $55 million as a reported number, not a guarantee.
How Gray became available is also muddy. AP reported that Boston declined a $30 million option in favor of a $5 million buyout. The Boston Globe described a mutual option with a $10 million buyout that Gray turned down. Either way, the 2027 option did not get exercised and he hit the market. Nobody has told us what Boston put in front of him, so anybody claiming to know is guessing.
Here is what we do know about the player. Hitters struggled against him the third time through the order, where he held them to a .180/.235/.280 slash line. Third time through is the stretch of a game where starters get cooked and bullpens get called early. A rotation without that kind of starter feels it every night. The bullpen covers the difference, and by August that adds up.
Craig Breslow said before the signing that Gray “was fantastic for us” and that “I think the rotation is in a really good place.” Both can be true. The first line is a eulogy. The second is a bet.
Jared Carrabis, for one, says he can’t blame Gray for “shooting us straight” on the way out.
I will look back on the Sonny Gray Red Sox Era fondly, even though it ended weird?
He pitched great, should’ve been an All Star, great leader, and in the end was brutally honest. Guy didn’t wanna be here after it was all said and done. Can’t blame him for shooting us straight.
— Jared Carrabis (@Jared_Carrabis) November 18, 2026
The case for moving on is real, and Fox laid it out: there is risk in giving multiple years to a 37-year-old. His strikeout rate went from 30.3% in 2024 to 26.7% in 2025 and 21.8% in 2026. A steady slide, and a pitcher who gets fewer strikeouts every year has to lean harder on defense, sequencing and luck. Gray pitched to a 2.72 ERA anyway, which is either a craftsman at work or a regression waiting for a mailing address. Minnesota just agreed to pay to find out. He pitched in Minnesota in 2022 and 2023, so they know exactly what they bought.
That is why I land on rotation hole, with a footnote. If Boston saw the strikeout numbers and decided age 37 was a bad place to spend, fine, that is a defensible read. (The sources do not agree on whether it was Boston’s call or Gray’s.) But the discipline only counts if somebody replaces those 29 starts. Right now the only thing on the record is a president of baseball operations saying the rotation looks good.
I will believe it when I see the name that goes in Gray’s slot on opening day.