| American League |
National League |
| Pos. |
Player |
Team |
Pos. |
Player |
Team |
| 2009 |
2009 |
| P |
Mark Buehrle |
Chicago |
P |
Adam Wainwright |
St. Louis |
| C |
Joe Mauer |
Minnesota |
C |
Yadier Molina |
St. Louis |
| 1B |
Mark Teixeira |
New York |
1B |
Adrian Gonzalez |
San Diego |
| 2B |
Placido Polanco |
Detroit |
2B |
Orlando Hudson |
Los Angeles |
| 3B |
Evan Longoria |
Tampa Bay |
3B |
Ryan Zimmerman |
Washington |
| SS |
Derek Jeter |
New York |
SS |
Jimmy Rollins |
Philadelphia |
| OF |
Torii Hunter |
Los Angeles |
OF |
Michael Bourn |
Houston |
| OF |
Adam Jones |
Baltimore |
OF |
Matt Kemp |
Los Angeles |
| OF |
Ichiro Suzuki |
Seattle |
OF |
Shane Victorino |
Philadelphia |