| American League | National League | ||||
| Pos. | Player | Team | Pos. | Player | Team |
| 2009 | 2009 | ||||
| P | Mark Buehrle | Chicago | P | Adam Wainwright | St. Louis |
| C | Joe Mauer | Minnesota | C | Yadier Molina | St. Louis |
| 1B | Mark Teixeira | New York | 1B | Adrian Gonzalez | San Diego |
| 2B | Placido Polanco | Detroit | 2B | Orlando Hudson | Los Angeles |
| 3B | Evan Longoria | Tampa Bay | 3B | Ryan Zimmerman | Washington |
| SS | Derek Jeter | New York | SS | Jimmy Rollins | Philadelphia |
| OF | Torii Hunter | Los Angeles | OF | Michael Bourn | Houston |
| OF | Adam Jones | Baltimore | OF | Matt Kemp | Los Angeles |
| OF | Ichiro Suzuki | Seattle | OF | Shane Victorino | Philadelphia |